College Senate Bulletin
Correspondence to Dennis Showers, School of Education, South 222C, showers@geneseo.edu, 245-5264
Note: Page numbers indicate pages as per the paper copy of the Bulletins.
Pages 41-53
November 9, 2006
Agenda for Senate Meeting on November 14, 2006Reports of the Standing Committees of the Senate
Undergraduate Curricula Meg Stolee
New Courses – First Reading:Graduate Academic Affairs Susan Salmon
New Program – First Reading
Master of Science in Education: Teaching in Multicultural Education (Grades 1-6)Revised Courses – First Reading
EDUC 501: Foundations of Education: Philosophical and Psychological Assumptions about the Nature of Learning
EDUC 503: Foundations of Education: School and Society
CURR 530: Language Arts Methods for the Elementary School
CURR 531: Multicultural Social Studies Methods for the Elementary School
CURR 532: Science Methods in the Elementary School
CURR 533: Mathematics Methods in the Elementary SchoolEDUC 560: Theory and Practice of Multicultural Education: subtitle
EDUC 401: Philosophy of Multicultural Education
EDUC 479: Creating a Multicultural ClassroomOld Business
Committee on Graduate Academic Affairs
Attendance: Brian Bennett, Irene Belyakov, Anne Eisenberg, Jennifer Katz, Koomi Kim, Jordan Kleiman, Sherry Schwartz, Kelly Griffin, Kelly Owens, Leigh O’Brien, Lee Schiffel, Susan Salmon
Visitors: Don Marozas, Steve West, Linda Steet, David Granger, Jane Fowler-Morse
General Information
Old Business to finish from previous committee meeting
New Business
· Susan Salmon mentioned to the group that revisions are still being made on the CURR 533: Mathematics Methods in the Elementary School program descriptions and bibliography. Our committee requested these revisions last meeting. (Refer to the minutes of 10/3/06; CSB #2, pp 27-29) The writer has promised that it will be done soon. Our committee would like to be able to report back to the College Senate regarding the TIME program at the November meeting.
· Susan Salmon proposed that our committee vote for the 533 course change via email rather than hold another meeting in October. This motion was moved by Anne and seconded by Irene.
· Last item of business: Stephen West, the Associate Dean of the College came to our meeting to discuss the difference between 400 and 500 level courses. Our committee posed this question at the last meeting on 10/3/06. He stated that the difference presently is minimal; however, historically the course numbering had greater significance.
· He claimed that 30 years ago a majority of the liberal arts departments had graduate programs. At that time, there was an occasional 400 level class which was considered to be an upper level undergraduate/ low level graduate course.
· However, currently there are fewer graduate programs at Geneseo. The largest existing programs happen to be the Communicative Disorders and Sciences programs. Therefore, today the only true distinction between these two level courses is that the School of Education prohibits undergraduates from taking 500 level courses.
· Stephen West cautioned that the policy regarding School of Education students taking graduate courses is different in the student handbook, than as stated on forms given to students.
· He believed that the policy states that a student within 11 hours of graduation and with an acceptable G.P.A. may take a 400 level graduate course and a 500 level course by permission only. He was not certain without paperwork in front of him.
· Susan Salmon proposed to adjourn the meeting and Jennifer Katz moved the motion to adjourn.
GCC: Descriptions of Proposed Course and Program Changes for Senate Consideration 11/14/06
Senators or others who wish to read these course proposals in their entirety may go to: http://dean.geneseo.edu/?pg=ucc/forms.html. Click on the Senators link at the bottom of the page and log on with your Geneseo email user name and password. This links to list of departments or programs with current proposals for revision. Clicking on any title takes you to a list of the course proposals currently under consideration.
Master of Science in Education: Teaching in Multicultural Education (Grades 1-6)
This course is designed to prepare teachers to work with children from differing ethnic, racial, linguistic, religious, gender, and language backgrounds, and children with special needs. It is also designed to prepare teachers to develop multicultural acceptance among children in a mono-cultural population. Offered fall only, and summer when demand is sufficient. 3(3-0)
EDUC 501, Foundations of Education: Philosophical and Psychological Assumptions about the Nature of Learning
CURR 530 Language Arts Methods for the Elementary School
CURR 531: Multicultural Social Studies Methods for the Elementary School
CURR 532: Science Methods in the Elementary School
EDUC 560, Theory and Practice of Multicultural Education: subtitle
Undergraduate Curriculum Committee Minutes
Members Present: S.A. Brainard, P.Case, J. Chester, R. Coloccia, R. Doggett, B. Fearn, K. Hinman, C. Leary, C. Shin, M. Stolee (Chair), A. Weibel, L. Zipp
Guests Present: David Aaagesen (Geog), Doug Baldwin (Comp Sci), Joan Ballard (Psych), Stephen West (Dean’s Office)
The meeting was convened at 4 PM. and began with introductions. The Chair explained role of the UUC.
S. West mentioned that the EDUC375 proposal had been withdrawn.
CSCI major revision proposal: D. Baldwin explained the intent. The proposal was unanimously approved.
ENVR minor revision proposal: D. Aagesen explained the changes. The proposal was unanimously approved.
GEOG major revision proposal: D. Aagesen said this was part of an ongoing review. The proposal was unanimously approved.
GEOG330 new course proposal: The proposal was unanimously approved.
GEOG340 new course proposal: It was noted that the proposal form lacked the statement of credit hours. Pursuant to that correction, the proposal was unanimously approved.
PHIL major revision proposal: C. Leary asked if the changes diminished the core knowledge base of a Philosophy major. J, Chester said that the new flexibility in requirements would benefit the majors who were not going to pursue graduate study in that field. He noted that previously required classes would still be offered and that majors who might pursue graduate study in Philosophy would be advised to enroll in them. A friendly amendment was offered to update reference to PHIL 260 (also proposed for change).Pursuant to that change, the proposal was unanimously approved.
PHIL260 course revision: this is a realistic upgrade to the 300-level at which the class has been taught for some time. The proposal was unanimously approved.
PHIL concentration deletion proposal: this is mandated because the State Education Department has determined it is no longer a valid concentration. The proposal was approved with one nay vote.
PSYC minor revision proposal: J. Ballard explained that this was necessary to ensure that transfer students who minored in Psychology actually took Geneseo Psychology classes. The proposal was unanimously approved.
PSYC major revision proposal: This reflects a tidying up of content areas so that they are internally consistent in class levels. Psych 260 (Abnormal) & PSYC 321 (Developmental) will be deleted from their respective content areas and become eligible for use as electives. The proposal was unanimously approved.
PSYCH397 new course proposal: This will diminish the need for directed studies and will provide students with common research experiences. The proposal was unanimously approved.
The Chair confirmed the next meeting for November 7, 2006 at 4 PM in Sturges 105. The meeting was adjourned at 4:40 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Louise Zipp
Faculty Affairs Committee Meeting Minutes
I. Attendance:
S. Bosch, B. Colón, A. Gu, J. Lovett, P. MacLean, J. McLean, J. Morse, R. McKnight, A. Stanley, Y. Zhang, J. Zook.
Guests: Kerry McKeever and David Granger (from the Task Force on Advising)
II. General Information
§ J. Morse called the meeting to order at 4:05 p.m.
§ The committee approved the minutes of the October 13 meeting and the agenda of today’s meeting
III. Old Business:
§ J. Morse will send the IDEA short form to committee members.
§ Members briefly discussed the question of security of the online SOFIs, as per the mail from student member Jeff Olodort, which J. Morse will forward to committee members. The Committee agreed that this issue ought to be included in the Nov. 28 meeting.
§ The guests discussed the activities of the President’s Task force on Advising and introduced the results from the student advisement surveys.
§ The committee discussed the difficulties of measuring advising activities and how to reward faculty for the contribution of advisement to the mission of the College. Members agreed that advising students is important.
§ The guests will provide the committee members with information about “best advising practices in the nation;” McKeever discussed what she learned at the NACADA Conference and will forward forms that she obtained at the conference for evaluating advising. Pursuant to the recommendation of the Task Force on Faculty Roles, Rewards, and Evaluation, the committee members will consider the feasibility of some form of evaluating advisement activities at SUNY Geneseo.
§ The guests invited the committee members to see the demonstration of a software program called Advisor Track, which tracks advisement issues, a demonstration of which the Task Force on Advising will be viewing in the near future.
§ The Committee and the guests discussed their charges regarding the issue of advisement, which overlap to some extent. The Committee’s charge is to operationalize the report from the Task Force on Faculty Roles, Rewards, and Evaluation, which recommends devising some mode of evaluating the advisement activities of individual faculty members for purposes of renewal, promotion, and continuing appointment. The Task Force on Advisement’s charge, on the other hand, is to make recommendation to improve advisement on campus in general.
§ The Committee expressed interest in seeing the results of the surveys that the Task Force on Advisement has used to collect data from chairs, faculty members, and students. The guests from the Task Force on Advisement reported a high level of participation in the student survey; over 4,0000 students responded. In general, the data showed a high level of satisfaction with advising, but the Task Force guests stressed that the Task Force has not yet analyzed the data from the three surveys. The faculty survey is not yet completed and will remain open until Nov. 13.
§ The Committee agreed that it seems premature to move forward on working on a method of evaluating advisement until the data on advisement is collected and analyzed and recommendations made by the Task Force on Advising. Some committee members expressed caution about having a universal mode of evaluation where advising practices differ widely among departments and advising loads vary considerably.
§ The committee did not take up other business from the agenda pertaining to recommendations of the Task Force on Faculty Roles, Rewards, and Evaluation, since these discussions took up the meeting time and then some.
§ The Committee briefly discussed the need to take up the recommendation of the Task Force on Faculty Roles, Rewards, and Evaluation regarding Form H, or whatever form is used to evaluate faculty for purposes of renewal, promotion, and continuing appointment. Revisions to this form, a Personnel Form, (called “Per Form” in the Task Force report) may be connected to any proposed evaluation of advising. Committee members are asked to study this issue in the report.
IV. New Business:
§ A. Gu will write up an explanation of the issue, which he raised at the Oct 13 meeting, of lack of access to better performing mutual funds for the faculty’s retirement investments. The Committee will consider forwarding this explanation as a recommendation to the proper authority, probably the UUP, to look into further.
The meeting was adjourned at 5:10 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Anthony Yanxiang Gu
Undergraduate Curriculum Committee Minutes
The meeting was called to order at 4:00, in Sturges 105.
Members present: M. Stolee (chair), J. Chester, K. Hinman, C. Leary, L. Zipp, R. Coloccia, N. Greco, S. Brainard, G. Towsley, C. Shin, A. Weibel, P. Case, R. Doggett
Guests: S West, D. Aagesen, D. Baldwin, J. Katz, J. Koch, M. Blood
Proposals:
CSCI 115 – Digital Futures, Human Futures - new course – approved
There is no significant overlap with CSCI 114.
GEOG 348 - Sports Geography – new course – approved
The credit assignment for the course should read 3(3-0).
PLSC 222 – Politics of East Asia - new course- approved
These six courses have been created for new staff.
PLSC 223 – Politics of South Asia - new course- approved
PLSC 227 – Democratization - new course- approved
PLSC 312 – American Social Policy - new course- approved
PLSC 321 – State and Society in the Nonwestern World - new course - approved
PLSC 341 – Democracy and International Relations - new course- approved
WMST 100 – Introduction to Women’s studies - new course - approved
These courses are designed to develop a general knowledge base for the minor.
WMST 201 – Topics in Women’s Studies: (Subtitle) – course revision - approved
WMST 210 – Race, Class, and Gender - new course - approved
Changes have been made in the description of the course.
WMST 220 – Gender and Sexualities - new course - approved
WMST 301 – Seminar in Women’s Studies - delete course - approved
Women’s Studies Minor – revised program – approved
New Business – A question for future discussion – “What should be the guidelines for a guide syllabus for a new course?
The meeting was adjourned at 4:54.
UCC: Descriptions of Proposed Course and Program Changes for Senate Consideration 11/14/06
Senators or others who wish to read these course proposals in their entirety may go to: http://dean.geneseo.edu/?pg=ucc/forms.html. Click on the Senators link at the bottom of the page and log on with your Geneseo email user name and password. This links to list of departments or programs with current proposals for revision. Clicking on any title takes you to a list of the course proposals currently under consideration.
New Courses – First Reading:
GEOG 340: Pyrogeography; A thorough study of wildland fire as an influence on natural processes, culture and politics, spanning the human and physical divisions of the geographic discipline. Discussion topics will include fire chemistry and behavior, fire weather, fire ecology, fire history data sources, fire in the US and a survey of global fire. Prerequisites: GEOG110, or permission of the instructor.
GEOG 348: Sports Geography; This course examines amateur and professional sports from a geographic perspective. It surveys the ways in which historical, cultural, political, economic, demographic and environmental factors have contributed to the origin and diffusion of sports. Analysis will be conducted at different spatial scales; local, regional, national and international. Topics include locational strategies and migration patterns of sports clubs and franchises, spatial analysis of sports regions and areas of player production, development of sports arenas and stadiums, economic and environmental impacts of sports, and factors influencing the transition of folk games to modern competitive sports. Geog 102 or Geog 123, or permission of the instructor, is a prerequisite for this course. 3 credit hours
PLSC 222: Politics of East Asia; This course examines the domestic and international politics of East Asia. How have historical and political factors shaped such varied polities, including a communist country contending with massive socioeconomic and political change and a constitutional monarchy with a parliamentary system? How successful have the countries of the region been in addressing the political and socioeconomic aspirations of their populations? Which countries have emerged as regional or global powers, and with what effect on the international system? Two major Asian powers, China and Japan, are studied in detail, and the considerable diversity of the region is explored through additional country studies. In addition, each student has the opportunity to pursue study of a pertinent topic of special interest through the individual project requirement. The course does not presuppose prior knowledge of East Asian history and politics. Prerequisites: PLSC 120. Credits 3(3-0). Offered every other fall. (i.e. Offered fall, odd years.)
PLSC 223: Politics of South Asia; This course explores the major political and socioeconomic forces shaping contemporary South Asia. We begin with an overview of South Asia (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, the Maldives, Nepal, and Afghanistan), emphasizing subcontinental factors such as the impact of colonization and anti-colonial freedom struggles; international relations; and regional conflicts such as Kashmir and the nuclearization of the Indo-Pakistani relationship. We then turn to the ways in which newly independent states have contended with challenges of governance, national unity, and socioeconomic development, through case studies of the states of the region. The major focus of the course is the evolution and nature of democratic and authoritarian regimes in the region. We also explore themes such as the relationship between religion and politics; socioeconomic development and the effects of globalization; and political participation by groups that are diverse in terms of language, gender, religion, caste, ideological affiliation, and class.
PLSC 227: Democratization; Democracy as both a political ideal and institutionalized system is relatively new in historical terms: the eighteenth century counted only three such polities (the US, the French Republic, and the Swiss Cantons). This number has increased steadily over time, even leading some to predict a trend toward near-total democratization globally. In what is termed the “third-wave” of democratization, over 80 countries around the world have moved from authoritarian to democratic systems, albeit sometimes slowly and in partial measure, just since the mid-1970s. However, there is no single clear path toward democratization, and the methods for—or even possibility of—assisting countries toward democratic goals remains a topic of acute political controversy.
PLSC 312: American Social Policy; This course presents an analysis of U.S. policy responses to poverty within the framework of the public policy process. The course will examine how definitions of the “deserving” and “undeserving” poor and Americans’ attitudes toward the causes of poverty influence the types of public policy implemented. Income maintenance programs, policies to encourage work, health insurance for low-income and elderly Americans, programs to meet basic needs, and how U.S. policy provides for children being raised in poverty will all be examined. The course will also consider the changing relationship between the national and state governments and a comparison of the U.S. social safety net to that available to residents of European nations. Prerequisites: PlSC 110 or permission of the instructor. Credits 3 (3-0). Offered spring, odd years.
PLSC 321: State and Society in the Non-Western World; This course examines state-society relations in comparative politics, focusing on the interplay among ideologies, institutions, interests, and identities in the nonwestern world. Readings include both theoretical works exploring these concepts and critical case studies. We begin with exploration of the adoption and adaptation of various political ideologies, sometimes arising from Western traditions and interactions with Western powers, that resulted in extremely varied political institutions throughout the nonwestern world. For example, parliamentary democracies have emerged in countries with remarkably different histories, including formerly fascist Japan and a number of former colonies. And yet other newly independent countries facing similar initial conditions adopted political systems as dissimilar as communism, democracy, and military authoritarianism. Prerequisites: PLSC 120. Credits 3 (3-0). Offered every spring.
PLSC 341: Democracy and International Relations; What is the connection between democracy and international politics? Would a more democratic world be a more peaceful world? Are democracies inherently more peaceful than nondemocracies? This course examines the concept of the democratic peace, beginning with Kant’s notion of the democratic pacific union. We then examine major contemporary works on democratic peace theory, arguments modifying our understanding of the democratic peace, and important critiques of this concept.
PSYC 397: Undergraduate Research Seminar; This course provides experience in formulating research projects and applying research techniques in psychology through participation in a faculty-supervised research project and a student-faculty research seminar. Prerequisites: Psyc 250, 251, and instructor permission. 3 credits. Offered every semester.
WMST 100: Introduction to Women’s Studies; This course is an introduction to the study of women and gender using interdisciplinary and cross-disciplinary approaches. It will include a feminist analysis of the construction and enforcement of gender differences and gender inequalities in various contexts, with an emphasis on the intersection of race, class, sexuality, and nationality in the lives of women. Topics include but are not limited to: historical constructions of gender, feminist activism, women’s issues in global perspective, women’s health and reproductive rights, media representations of gender, domestic violence and sexual assault, and feminist theories. Credits: 3(3-0). Offered every spring
WMST 201: Topics in Women’s Studies; This course provides an opportunity for students to critically study interdisciplinary topics particular to women’s social, political, aesthetic, and domestic lives. Because of the Women’s Studies Program’s commitment to studying the interstices and intersections of gender, race, sexuality, and class, all topics approved for this course must devote a significant portion of their content to women of color, and, where appropriate, to questions of class. Each section of the course is team-taught by faculty from two different disciplines. Credits: 3(3-0). Offered every fall
WMST 210: Race, Class and Gender; This course uses multiple disciplines to explore how identity categories of gender, race, and class intersect. Students will explore and critique relations of power in families, societies, and cultures. In class discussion and in writing, students will reflect on their own ideas and thought processes, and they will engage respectfully with differing ideas. Credits: 3(3-0). Offered fall, odd years.
WMST 220: Gender and Sexualities; This course will involve a multi-disciplinary, feminist exploration of the intersections of gender, culture, and sexuality. The experiences of historically devalued groups, including girls and women, sexual minorities, and people of color will be emphasized.
Revised Courses – First Reading:
Revised Programs – First Reading:
Environmental Studies minor – additions and deletions of courses within the minor: Biol 314 (Biodiversity), Biol 235 (Disease and the Developing World) and Pyrogeography (Geog 340) are all appropriate for an interdisciplinary minor in environmental studies. Geog 351, Geog 368, Geog 380 and Gsci 348 have all been deleted from the College curriculum.
GEOG major – addition of new courses and a revised course to the major:
Geog 261, Geography of North America's title was changed to Geography of the United States, with Senate approval on 4/18/06. Remains under "Basic Requirements" of the major
Geog 359, Geography of Canada, is a new course, Senate approved 4/18/06. It, as initially proposed, will fulfill the Advanced Regional component of the major.
Geog 120, N/Meteorology, is a new course, Senate approved 1/24/06. It, as initially proposed, will serve as an elective option in the major.
Geog 391, Cartography Seminar: (subtitle) is a new slot course, Senate approved 12/6/05. It, as initially proposed, will serve as an elective option in the major. Since it is a 1-credit hour course, notice is posted that two other 3-credit hour GEOG electives are needed with the course.PHIL major – change requirements: The main reason for eliminating the disjunctive requirement (either Phil 260, or Phil 275, or Phil 317) for a Philosophy Major is to increase the flexibility of the Major, by increasing the minimum number of electives from 6 to 9 credits. Our current Major course requirements are unusually rigid compared to those of comparable institutions (comparable data from other institutions is available upon request, and can be checked on-line). The change will give students more freedom in selecting courses for the Major.
PSYC minor – add requirement that at least 9 credits in the major be completed at Geneseo.
Women’s Studies Minor - Women’s Studies has redesigned its entire curriculum in response to current practices nationally in Women’s Studies, the dwindling numbers of minors, and the poor allocation of current Women’s Studies resources. Specifically we are adding an introductory course to attract students early in their college careers (Introduction to Women’s Studies). We are designing two required 200 level courses (WMST 210: Race, Class and Gender and WMST 220: Gender and Sexualities) and a rotating topics course that is recommended as a Women’s Studies elective (WMST 201: Topics in Women’s Studies). Finally, we are adding a capstone experience to be filled with one of two individualized courses (WMST 399: Research or Creative Project in Women’s Studies or WMST 395: Internship in Women’s Studies). No faculty are assigned to teach these senior level courses, but students must find mentors to direct their capstone experiences, which are approved by the coordinator of Women’s Studies in consultation with the Women’s Studies Advisory Group. Further, the Women’s Studies Advisory Group has developed an application process for faculty both wishing to teach a WMST course or to list their departmental courses as an elective in Women’s Studies. The current minor has only two offerings in Women’s Studies, none at the 100 level, and only one of which is required. While Women’s Studies in inherently interdisciplinary, the new formulation assumes that there is a coherent body of material to be learned in the 100 and 200 level courses, and that students will benefit from an individualized capstone experience.
Deleted Programs – First Reading:
At the October 24 GCC Meeting The following motion was passed:
· Susan Salmon proposed that our committee vote for the 533 course change via email rather than hold another meeting in October. This motion was moved by Anne and seconded by Irene.
Voting was conducted from November 5 to 9. Fourteen members of the Committee cast votes (a quorum of the Committee is eight). The motion to approve CURR 533 passed.
GCC: Description of Proposed Course CURR 533 Changes for Senate Consideration 11/14/06
Senators or others who wish to read these course proposals in their entirety may go to: http://dean.geneseo.edu/?pg=ucc/forms.html. Click on the Senators link at the bottom of the page and log on with your Geneseo email user name and password. This links to list of departments or programs with current proposals for revision. Clicking on any title takes you to a list of the course proposals currently under consideration.
CURR 533: Mathematics Methods in the Elementary School